A little extoller/CRA clarification

[NaCl Catapulto]

Tried a game today, Hexeris, Bronzeback, AG, and other assorted goodies vs a Deneghra lsit at 35pts. Figured I'd strat with the uphill battles first....

It did not go well.

Anyways, a situation came up wherein the Extoller granted Guidance to a nearby Arcuarii, who then led in a CRA against a pistol wraith with his newly-magic'd harpoon. Is this kosher? The Guidance ability bears none of the usual "may not participate in cma/cra" limitations that often accompany single-attack enchantments like Siege's explosivo. I know how CRA, eyeless sight (on one model) and stealth interact, but what of the magic weapon quality? Does the whole CRA become magic, provided the leaders attack is?

[TheOrange]

I would imagine that since those joining in the CRA don't have magic weapons they still can't target the pistol wrath so can't be legal participants in the CRA.

[Wolfbane]

An incorporeal model can be a target, it can't be damaged by non-magical weapons. If the weapon the leader of the CRA is using is magical, I guess this is correct.

[Yertle4]

Wow, I didn't even realize that it was target model rather than model/unit. That makes Ferox and Venators even crappier.

Well, at least it got gunfighter, and boosting attack/damage rolls :)

[fuzzypants]

i believe the cra just adds bonuses and has no efect on the weapon. so if the modal leading the cra has magic attack then the cra has it.

[NaCl Catapulto]

Aye, it seems like it would work that way (CRA become magic). Thanks for the responses - I've been waiting to hear something on this note.