Effective 25 pt list Journeyman League

[Vaquero]

Hi guys

I'm sort of stuck between two different lists ... next week is Week Four and we can swap casters. Still have to take Battlepack though.. Anyhow the two lists I am torn between are:

e. Lylyth
4x Shredders
Carnivean
Ravagore
Blighted Shepherd

Basically just a shoot em down list that seems to me like it could be effective.

However.. I also like:

p. Thagrosh
4 x Shredders
Carnivean
Throne of Everblight
Strider Deathstalker

The idea of this list is to use fog of war while advancing, and shove both Throne and Carnivean down enemy throat and have them deal with one of the two, and if need be (probably), using his feat to revive Carnivean while Deathstalker tries to get solo's. Bit of a brute force/attrition I am trying for.

Looking for some people with good experience at this level for advice! Thanks everyone

[PG_gojira316]

I'd go with the pThagrosh list since. It pairs up with the warpack models better than eLylyth does.